Syllabus says something like: The purpose of these how to write a good text response essay is to help you clarify your understanding of the readings and to help you think critically about the issues. These assignments should be two-thirds to one page, typewritten reactions or questions about some specific issue which you find compelling in the readings.
On occasion, I will suggest a specific topic in advance. Important: your paper must not simply sum up the reading or repeat points made there. Rather, you must try to raise a question or discuss some original insight. QUESTION: What should a “short paper” be like? Below are a few examples of what you might do-and should not do-to fulfill this assignment. Let’s say the reading is an essay by a philosopher defending free access to abortion. In the essay, the author argues that that a woman has the right to control what happens to her body and because a fetus is not a person in the full sense, the government has no right to make abortion illegal.
The author spends time describing and defending the important concept of “person” and also explains why the government has a duty to respect the individual citizen’s privacy. 1: Challenge a key concept with a counterexample. Discusses how the author defines the word “person” and focuses on one major counterexample that shows the definition to be inadequate. Example: by defining “person” in the author’s way, we would have to accept, by this same definition, that anyone on life support is not a person, either. Therefore, the definition is too broad. 2: Recognizes why a concept is important and extends discussion to issues outside the reading. Discusses why the right to control her body is so important to a woman, and gives an example of how that right is violated in other situations.
3: Compares the role a concept plays in two different arguments. 4: Uses an important concept in reading to raise a difficult question. Discusses how “person” is defined in other ethical situations, e. Raises the provocative question: if human infants and mature animals are similar in crucial respects, does this mean that meat is murder? 5: Focuses on something the author’s overall strategy in the essay by asking a specific question. For example, why the author has chosen to focus on the definition of “person” to decide the abortion issue.
6: Spells out a list of unclear items in reading. Here, the writer chooses two or three major points in the reading they did not understand, noting specific passages in the text. This is just a short list of ways a paper might be creative and critical. What other ways can you think of? 1: Simply summarizes what author says in reading. 3: Discusses reading assigned, but makes obvious mistakes about what the author said. Enjoy proficient essay writing and custom writing services provided by professional academic writers.